I’ve used words like “flail” and “flummox” in all too many
blogposts but today I’m invoking both, in advance, as I finally put fingers to
keyboard and write about Svetlana Kuznetsova’s Анатомия Луны (The
Anatomy of the Moon). I read Anatomy for the first time,
electronically, in January, then read it in book form several months later. Now
I’m translating the novel, finishing a first draft. But I’m still unsure what or
how to write about Anatomy. As with any book, the more I translate, the
more I see in the book. But the more I see in the book, the more I realize
there’s still more to learn and grasp. When I translate, I read, I write, and I
soak up details and motifs, making connections and finding ways to connect my emotional
and intellectual reactions to the text. I think this is one of the biggest
reasons I love translation so much, even if I’m still not always able to
explain what I feel or understand in my books.
If I had to choose one word to describe The Anatomy of the
Moon, it might (likely?) be “trauma.” I suppose that’s especially fitting
since trauma often accompanies coming of age, something I also see in Anatomy,
albeit in multiple stages at the life of Lo, the redheaded narrator who sees
herself as a banshee. (Yes,
“Lo,” like that other Lo; this is a thread I have yet to pull by rereading Lolita.
And yes, that most famous line does echo in Anatomy…) Lo lives in a sort
of ghetto, a borough called 20/20. She’s an artist and she escaped to
20/20 after the counterfeit art ring she was involved with was busted. (!) 20/20
is filled with others who have nowhere else to go. Among them is a Russian gang
leader, a sort of gang manager; he was dumped in
20/20 by the police. He’s missing most of his nose. Others in the area are
missing things, too: physical fingers or limbs, parents, or God, who’s
left the premises for other parts of the universe.
God’s absence and the vacuum it creates on Planet Earth is one
of the central motifs in Anatomy. At one point (I’ll paraphrase a bit
here), Lo asks God to come back to pat people’s heads and protect them, be they
sinners, prostitutes, or banshees shivering like little birds in the cold
winter. She’s essentially praying for everyone. Residents of 20/20 seem to live
on adrenaline (there’s brutal ethnic gang warfare, particularly between Russian
and Salvadoran groups; this almost feels geopolitical, allegorical) and anesthetics
like bootleg absinthe and the cannabis that Fedya Afrikanets, the Russian gang’s
head warrior grows in mass quantity at his apartment by the waterfront. The
artists in the area – one’s surname is Satanov, which is pretty clear, another’s
is Grobin, nicknamed “Grob,” or coffin – avoid the rumbles but join in at the gang’s
gritty bar that’s known as a teahouse.
I could write pages and pages about the many plot elements
and turns in Anatomy – the Lo-Grob-Afrikanets love triangle, the meanings
of characters’ losses of body parts and relatives, and the many twists in gang and
even drug trafficking relations – but what underlies everything, at least to my
mind, is art and authenticity. Among some beautiful descriptions of winter (blizzards,
blocks of ice sticking out of the Neva-like river, wind rattling in ventilation
shafts, I love this northern, Petersburgesque stuff) and horrifying accounts of
battles and abuse, some in the past, some in the present, are threads about
art. Yesterday’s work included what I might call a rant (I love translating a
good rant!) about art, praising cave art in Lascaux and taking Duchamp’s Fountain
to task, while also referencing (for the second time) Piero Manzoni’s Artist’s
Shit. God is gone, beauty is gone, Van Gogh is crying. Art has become
an acquisition, something Lo and her fellow counterfeiters capitalize on in a
consumer-oriented society that cares more about money and collections than
appreciation of beauty and human beings… That society, which is geographically close
but on another planet both socially and economically, treats people like the residents
of 20/20 as disposable. And gang warfare, ethnic hatreds and ugly stereotypes, extreme
poverty abound in 20/20. There’s a lot of extremely uncomfortable material in Anatomy.
The book feels like a warning, a cautionary tale about what happens when the
world goes off-kilter, when cans of crap are sold as art, and people don’t
count. Of course there are many acts of kindness among friends and allies, not to
mention some humor, and Kuznetsova’s characters aren’t all bad – more than anything,
they’re people who’ve gone astray and have had little or no positive guidance
in their lives – but it’s the bigger picture, the one that includes an absent God,
a God who’s on the lam, that stays with me most. That and Fedya’s statement
that the residents of 20/20 are like scraps of wood after a shipwreck. Indeed
they are. Shipwreck. Fragmentation. Kuznetsova hammers on motifs like these,
giving the novel a rhythm that doesn’t let the reader forget the trauma, the violence,
and what’s missing in everyday lives.
I suppose that’s why Anatomy grabbed me so strongly
the first time I read it: the novel kept me up at night, both as I read and as I
considered what I was reading, thinking about the characters’ many sides, both
as imaginary people who feel almost real and, even more as, well, literary
devices created to convey the author’s messages. Anatomy still keeps me
up because I still can’t forget about it. That’s not just because I’m
translating and it’s not just that Kuznetsova writes about people on the
margins who barely exist for most of the world, about haves and have-nots,
about violence, about deep societal divisions, about things that shouldn’t
happen. It’s because what she writes feels so phantasmagorically true and sad that it won’t
leave me alone.
This may seem an odd way to conclude a post but no book has
made me recall, so vividly, a sociology course I took years ago with Philip Rieff. Rieff showed
us films – he called us “the video generation,” a term I resented because I’ve
always been so book-oriented – and discussed the ways the films portrayed the
breakdown of what he called the sacred order. He often said he hoped that, decades
hence, we’d face situations that would bring back memories of the course and our
discussions of the sacred order. I’m not sure if I first thought of Rieff because
of Anatomy’s depiction of a broken sacred order or because one of the films
we watched was Luis Buñuel’s The Phantom of Liberty, where toilets
play a major role in one scene. Either way, Rieff’s teachings on the sacred
order – a framework I don’t think of in strictly religious terms – helped shape
my views of the novel and how it fits with my own perceptions of the world. My only
regret in focusing here on the sacred order is that I’ve held back on so many other
layers, including formal aspects of the book – not to mention the wonderful rabbit holes
Anatomy offers, what with astronomy, banshees (very interesting!), art
history (Breughel!), paint
colors for the Eiffel tower, and a zillion other things – as, flummoxed, I flailed
my way through writing this post.
Up Next: Marina and Sergei Dyachenko’s The Ritual,
about, how about this, a princess and a dragon. Aleksei Polyarinov’s The
Reef, a Big Book finalist.
Disclaimers and Disclosures: The usual.
I’m translating The Anatomy of the Moon (author commissioned, no publisher as yet) and the author provided me with
copies of the novel.